Follow Up Medical Study of 263 Chinese Babies and Children Adopted by American Families
Nancy W. Hendrie, M.D.,
Pediatric Consultant, Sharing in Adoption, Falmouth, Maine
There is a great deal of interest in the health of Chinese orphans
adopted by American parents. What is their overall health and how do they
fare after they arrive in their new homes?
This study is of 263 children, 5 of them boys, adopted from China
between September 1991 and June 1996 (the majority of the children were
adopted after the spring of 1994). As a pediatric consultant, I traveled
almost monthly between July of 1994 and July of 1996, providing health
examinations and care to over 235 Chinese babies and children during the two
-week adoption process.
At home, I have been in frequent touch with many of the families who
participated in this study. Questionnaires were sent to 324 adopting parents,
requiring answers from their medical doctors for specific laboratory results,
and developmental and behavioral assessment by parents and doctors. There
were 263 returns, for a 81% response rate; this sample is statistically
excellent, as it is large, and represents children from 26 orphanages in 8
provinces.
For space reasons here, the following is only a summary of the study.
Hepatitis B status :
- Hepatitis B surface antigen [carrier state for Hep B] 251 infants/children were tested, or 96% of the group.
96% negative [ 243 infants/children were negative for hep B ]
3.2% positive [ 8 infants/children of 251 were positive for Hep B surface antigen
[11 infants/children were not tested]
1 child who tested positive on arrival, converted to negative status without treatment
six months later [Comment: about 1% per year may convert to neg.]
1 child who tested positive on arrival in 1994, and had abnormal liver function tests, was treated with Interferon, and is negative as of 1996, including Hep B viral DNA undetectable.
[Comment: interferon treatment has been shown in quite a number of studies to be very helpful
in those children who do have/develop abnormal liver enzymes, and with fewer side effects than previously thought.]
The other 6 infants/children who remain positive all have normal liver
function tests, and are totally healthy. They are monitored regularly by their doctors.
- Hepatitis B antibody [signifying that the infant/child once had the
infection, got over it without harm, and is now permanently immune]
211 infant/child test {81% tested }
14 % immune [30 inf./child. of 211 were positive [immune]
By extrapolation, 37 infants/child of the total 263 were immune :
[Comment: 7 infants/children undoubtedly received 3 shots each of hep B
vaccine in the US which they did not need - costs: pain and money, and
positively will not convert a positive to negative, as some parents were misinformed.]
- Hepatitis A Antibody [signifying that the infant/child once had the
infection, got over it without harm, and is now permanently immune]
114 infants/children tested = 44% tested
6% immune [7 inf./child. of 114 were positive [immune]
Comment: currently this note is of academic interest only, but Hep A vaccine will be increasingly widely used in the future, and the test can be included in “hepatitis panel request” using no more blood and at very minimal cost.
- Lead testing:
207 inf/child. tested = 80% tested within 3 months of arriving in US
12% [25 inf/child. ] had abnormal levels
6.8% [14 inf/child ] had levels 10 - 15 micrograms 1.4% [3 inf/child ]had levels 15 - 20 micrograms
1.4 % [ 3 inf/child ] had levels 20-25 micrograms
2.5% [ 5 inf/child ] had levels over 25 micrograms
[3 of these children, with levels 37,37, and 50 were treated with lead lowering medications] [Comment: An additional 8 inf/child. were lead tested
Later [5 to 12 months after arrival] and found to have lead levels above 10;
one child had a level of 16 mcg 5 months after arrival, one child had 14
mcg 8 mos after arrival. It is possible, but unlikely, that they picked up
lead in the US: It is possible, and likely, that they had really high levels
on arrival, and perhaps should have been treated.
Adding the "late positives" to those tested in the
arbitrarily set 3 mos window, !6 % of the children arrived with lead levels
over the US safe standard of 10 micrograms.
Lead, and its implications, is a vast topic which could
be explored in a later newsletter. Many feel the US standard of 10 is too
low:
- Syphilis Status ; Negative test [signifies that the infant/child does not
have syphilis]
108 infants/children were tested = 41% tested
0 infants/children had the infection
- AIDS
42 infants/children tested; none were positive
[Comment: no AIDS positive Chinese adoptee has been reported
in the US]
- Tuberculosis Status: Negative test signifies that the inf./child had not been
significantly exposed to Tb and did not have the infection
222 infants/children tested = 85% tested
1.5% positive [4 infants/children were positive for Tb
exposure
[Comment: None of the skin-test positive infants/children
had Tb by x-ray exam. Some were treated with isoniazid
preventively, all are healthy.]
- Intestinal Parasites and Bacteria
229 infants/children tested = 87% tested
12% positive [27 infants/children were positive for parasites or bacteria]
[Comment: all children are healthy now; some did not even need treatment.]
- Thyroid Hormone testing
116 infants/children were tested = 44% tested
4% abnormal [ 5 inf/child. of 116 had abnormal
results]
[Comment: All five children have been treated and are
normal. If all 263 inf/child were tested, one would
expect 10 abnormal results. Thyroid abnormality can
effect cognition and often has no obvious physical signs.
China has large areas without iodine, necessary for thyroid function,
available.]
- Complete Blood Count testing
243 infants/children were tested = 93% tested
12% [ 29 inf/child had hemoglobin counts less than 11
milligrams]
5% [12 infants/children had hemoglobin counts less
than 10 milligrams] [Comment: Most
of the children were treated with iron rich feeding; a
few required medicinal iron; all are now normal.]
[8 children were found to have thalessemia trait, a
harmless genetic mild anemia which requires no treatment.]
- Other Medical Issues [N=263]
About 12 of the infants/children were adopted into families where the
child's special need was expected from the medical report sent from China
ahead of the adoption. These medical problems included extra fingers and
toes, missing fingers and toes, cleft lip and/or cleft palate, crossed eyes,
club foot, heart murmurs, hearing loss, and rickets. All these children have
received thorough medical care, some needing surgery, and are doing well.
Several other children were found to have medical issues on exam in China such
as dental problems, congenital hip dysplasia, heart defects not requiring
surgery (ventricular septal defect, pulmonic stenosis), and crossed eyes
(strabismus). All these children came home with their families by choice.Two
children developed serious seizure disorders as they matured: both have been
treated at university medical centers, and their seizures controlled by
medications. Two children were found to have congenital hip dislocations;
both have been treated, and are now normal. Otherwise, there have been the
same types of childhood infections - ears, chest infections, stomach and bowel
upsets- as are seen worldwide in all children, but actually fewer than
expected. There have been no deaths.
- Behavior and Developmental Assessment [N=260 ]
7% [18 children] have been found to have significant expressive
language delay
6% [15 inf./child] have had mild motor delay [ past the usual 3
months period we anticipate for “catch up”]
3% [ 9 inf/child] have had moderate motor delay
1% [3 inf/child] have had moderately severe motor delay
[Comment: Most of these children have been working with
their parents in "Early Intervention" programs, and
even the most significantly delayed has made
progress.
3% [8 children ] were said by their families to have moderate to
severe behavior issues.
1 child, adopted at 3 yrs, had severe attachment problems.
Her very loving family has worked very hard on this and she is now fine.
2 parents of infants 8-10 months reported attachment issues, now resolved.
4 families said their child had problems with temper tantrums, 2 reported "very aggressive" behavior, and 2 "very stubborn".
40% [104 children] were reported by their doctors and/or parents
to be "superior in intelligence; advanced in all areas." The children were further described by
such phrases: "a genius". "a great athlete", "a beauty". "a great joy", "she is a very social,
outgoing child", "I cannot imagine my life without her", "She is imaginative, humorous and a delight",
"You would think she practically had a PhD degree."
Conclusion: The 263 Chinese adoptees followed in this study are for the most
part extraordinarily healthy, and have done incredibly well adjusting to their
new families. The study is highly compressed here: I am pleased to answer
questions or hear comments at Sharing in Adoption, 366 US Rt. 1, Falmouth,
Maine, or at my home phone 207-442-7612 or Email : NHendrie@AOL.com [if I'm not off in China with parents and babies].
Editor's Note: Dr. Hendrie, formerly chief of pediatrics at Emerson Hospital
in Concord, Ma., has worked as a pediatric consultant for children adopted
from China since 1994. Traveling to China 21 times, she has seen more Chinese
orphanages and examined more of our adopted children than any other American
pediatrician. Curious to study the overall health of Chinese adoptees, Dr.
Hendrie undertook this study on her own, contacting many of the families she
had worked with. To date, it is the most complete picture of the general
health of Chinese adoptees that we currently have.
|